Who is Doug Ford?

Why these titles are fitting for Doug Ford:

1) Premier Hallway Medicine: he campaigned in 2018 to get rid of hallway medicine, instead, in the last seven years hallway medicine has increased 25%. Also, home care, primary care and long-term care are all in chaos.

2) Premier Gimmick: just like Trudeau he is using gimmicks to distract from his health care, cost of living and housing failures. He has promised each person $200: announced a study of primary care; and, said there will be a program to subsidize energy saving equipment, all just before an election. He could have done any of these at any time in the last seven years, instead he did nothing about the problems in health care, housing and the cost of living. He is hoping these gimmicks will distract from his failures.

3) Premier Corrupt: Doug Ford is the new definition of corruption: from giving away the greenbelt to wealthy developers and giving away valuable public waterfront property to a large multinational spa company, to shifting a billion dollars to the Weston family and other very wealthy people, he has done it all.  You can take your pick of corruption scandals.

Posted in corruption, Doug Ford, gimmicks, Hallway Medeicine, Ontario Election | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Overpayment to private financing consortium rises to 116-million-dollars: More money lost to Public Healthcare in Kingston.

An analysis of Providence Care’s redevelopment agreement shows the real costs of using a for-profit consortium to finance the new Providence Care Hospital is 116-million-dollars, or 3.9-million-dollars per year, more than if the government had financed the new building itself.

Providence Care Hospital’s audited statements show that the 2016 Development Accountability Agreement with ProjectCo, using the Bank of Nova Scotia as its financing lead, provided 30-year financing at 5.74% while Ontario Government’s 30 years bonds for the same time period only cost 2.9%. The extra interest paid on the 197-million-dollar construction costs over the 30 years is 116,179,943 dollars, or 3.9-million-dollars a year.

With either government financing or private financing, the province guarantees the repayment of the capital on the mortgage.  The documents show that Providence Care receives a direct payment from the province which it then passes onto ProjectCo paying off the principle on the mortgage. The extra interest payments come directly from Providence Care’s operating budget taking money away from other services.

The Kingston Health Coalition estimated that the cost using the for-profit financing proposal in its 2014 campaign against using a P3 model to finance and maintain the new hospital, would be 100-million-dollars more than using public, non-profit financing.  At that time, ten thousand Kingstonians voted, in a community referendum, against using the P3 model. The government ignored the population’s concerns, forced Providence Care to use the for-profit model, and now we are all paying for it.

The community was correct: this is a bad deal for Kingston’s health care.

The 3.9-million-dollars per year paid to international financiers could be better used on other urgent community health care needs, for example:

  • It could have been used to cover Providence Care’s 4-million-dollar COVID pandemic shortfall without having to consider service or maintenance cuts.
  • It could be used to pay the operating expenses of a new community primary care clinic.
  • It could be used to provide supportive housing for the many unhoused in the Kingston area.

These are some of the local health care needs that could be met rather than paying 3.9-million-dollars per year in excess profit to very wealthy companies and shareholders.

The excess cost at Providence Care is the second finding by the Kingston Health Coalition showing private for-profit health care costs more.  Earlier this year, the Coalition found that for-profit cataract surgeries in Kingston cost $247 dollars more per surgery, or about $2-million-dollars more per year, than if the same surgeries were done at the Kingston Health Sciences Center Hotel Dieu Hospital site. 

Posted in South Frontenac Township | Leave a comment

Health Coalition to Release New Report on KHSC’s Cataract Surgery Privatization

When: Thursday, February 15, 10am.

Where: Kingston Public Library,Central Branch, 130 Johnson Street, meeting room 2.

What: A report on Kingston Health Sciences Center’s privatization of cataract surgeries to a for-profit clinic will be released by the Kingston Health Coalition. The report reveals figures on the extra cost and irregularities in the contract.

All members of the public and the media are welcome to attend.

 

Posted in South Frontenac Township | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Ontario Health Coalition Action Plan

The Ontario Health Coalition has released its action plan to counter the Ford conservative governments attacks on public, non-profit health care.    It was passed by the Coalitions Executive Board after vigourous debate with many great suggestions from you yearly assembly.

Posted in South Frontenac Township | Tagged | 3 Comments

The Health Care Crisis: How We got Here and How We fix It. A Community Conversation

Thursday November 17th, 7pm by Zoom

Join us for a discussion on how the Ford government is threatening our public healthcare system and what we can do about it.  Your ideas and experiences are needed.  Feel free to invite anyone you know who has concerns about health care – our hospitals, long-term care, family doctors, home care – to join in.  It is an open discussion. All our voices are needed. The conversation will be lead by Ross Sutherland Chair of the Ontario Health Coalition. RSVP to receive the Zoom call details.

RSVP

Organized by the Lanark, Frontenac and Kingston NDP association.


Posted in South Frontenac Township | Tagged , | Leave a comment

The Election and Beyond

This will be my last Councillor post.  Election season is well under way and on October 24 there  will be a new South Frontenac Township Council. For the first time in a decade there will be no acclamations.  Both of the last two Councils ended with over 50% of the Council being unelected.  Thank you to all the candidates and residents for making this a more democratic election.

On the Election

For the past four years I enjoyed working with Randy Ruttan as the co-Councillor in Loughborough.  He has been a consistent voice for improving our lakes and environment.  His initiative brought about the Lake Ecosystem Committee which has become a strong voice for lake protection.  He has spoken up for increased Council transparency and accountability, and for improved public participation in Township decision-making.  If re-elected Randy has volunteered to take over the monthly newsletters on Township affairs.  He will continue to be a valuable voice around the Council table and deserves to be reelected.

I would also like to give a shout-out to Adam Trucott in Bedford District.  Adam stands out as a younger local resident who has a strong commitment to improving the environment, protecting lakes and wetlands and keeping the Township an affordable place to live.  Adam would be an important addition to Council.  If you live in Bedford, or know people who do, check out Adam and consider voting for him.  More information can be found at https://www.adamforcouncil.com/

The Official Plan

After years of work, the new Official Plan (OP) was delayed until after the election. Approving the new OP is one of the most important decisions the new Council will make. All candidates need to be questioned on it.  Will they support controlling development to protect our agricultural and environmentally sensitive areas?  Will they support policies that strengthen our hamlets and keep them affordable? Will they recognize the dangers of climate change and support an OP that helps mitigate that threat? Question your candidates and keep the pressure on after the election.

Taking Control of Subdivisions

Another big issue that was held over from the last Council was South Frontenac taking back control of subdivision approval. Over the last decade the County Council has asserted their right to dictate how subdivisions will be developed in the Township.  That means that the majority of people who make the final decision on subdivisions in South Frontenac are not accountable to the residents of South Frontenac. Once again, we need to know from our candidates how they stand on taking subdivision control back from the County?

The last eight years have been a pleasure.  I have learned a lot, participated in some good fights that I think improved the Township and met many great people.  I am enjoying immersing myself in health care politics and speaking out more on how to improve our public health care system.

I look forward to seeing you around the Township.

Talk soon, Ross.

Posted in South Frontenac Township | Tagged , , , , , | 2 Comments

Community; Climate; Change

Opening Council to the Public

The Township is slowly reopening from pandemic restrictions.  The state of emergency has been lifted.  Council passed a bylaw continuing the option for Councilors and the public to attend meetings virtually, including the live streaming of meetings. Allowing virtual attendance has dramatically increased the number of residents who listen to at least part of the Council meetings.  It also allows Councilors and staff to attend if they are away or if they are feeling unwell.  A good ongoing public health measure.

Public attendance at Council meetings will continue to be restricted until June.  At that time, the matter will be reconsidered. Due to the size of the Council chambers, we are looking at other options that have the technology, like the new Storrington Centre, to have larger in person meetings with simultaneous virtual capability.

One of the strengths of municipal government is that it is close to residents. People attending meetings in person, both to give deputations and listen to debate, is vital for local democracy: and its openness has been one of the strengths of South Frontenac Council.

Restrict the Ontario Land Tribunal

A few years ago, the Provincial Government gave the Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT) power over zoning and panning decisions made by local Councils. 

The OLT is an unelected, appointed body that is not accountable to the residents of South Frontenac. The province gave the OLT the power to make a final decision on planning matters based on a “best planning outcome” and not whether the proposed development is in compliance with approved official plans or consistent with provincial plans and policy.  Essentially, it can, and does, override municipal government decisions that were in compliance with locally approved bylaws and provincial legislation.

Ontario is the only province in Canada that gives a separate tribunal this power. The province’s use of the OLT has forced municipalities to spend millions of dollars defending Official Plans in expensive, time consuming and ultimately futile hearings.

South Frontenac Council passed a motion asking the province to remove Planning Act decisions from the OLT and increase the ability of local governments to represent their community.  If this comes to pass it would increase our communities’ control over development: a positive step in these times of rising political alienation.

A Climate Lens

Council passed the following motion:

“Moved that staff reports include a climate lens assessment: that is an assessment on how the subject matter of the report moves the Township towards zero greenhouse gas emissions; and comments on how the policy impacts the Township’s resilience to climate change”.

Staff and Council have been including climate considerations in many of their discussions.  This resolution will formalize the process and broaden it to apply to all policy. 

Sometime in the next few months Council should have staff recommendations for our first climate change action plan. Regardless of the specific initiatives proposed we still need to evaluate all polices on how they affect the overarching environmental challenge of our time.

Time to Move On

After much thought over the last couple of years I have decided to not seek reelection. One of the real joys of the last 8 years has been writing these reports and reading, and engaging with, your comments, both positive and negative.  Thank you all for being interested.  I will have more to say as we get to the end of this term.

If someone is thinking about running for Council, I would be happy to talk with them about my experiences.  Council could really use some younger women representatives.  At this point the “old boys club” is more than a metaphor for Council.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted in South Frontenac Township | 1 Comment

Community Building no Book Burning

Community Controlled Development

January was focused on the 2022 budget. The final debate and vote on the budget will take place mid-February.

One issue has become contentious: the hiring of a planning policy and compliance officer.

For years there have been many complaints about subdivision agreements not being followed, and smaller developments ignoring their conditions of approval.  Monumental amounts of staff time have been to fix problems from poor subdivision oversight, like on Morgan Drive.  Going forward significant resources will be needed to oversee detailed site plans for developments on Johnson’s Point and in Hartington. To meet current demands the Township has had to hire short-term contract planning staff to meet resident’s exceptions.

The is also significant pressure for new bylaws on a variety of issues, including an update to our sign bylaws to clean up our roadsides, control of Short-Term Rentals (STRs), and protection of our shorelines from clear cutting. The list could go on. Each bylaw, if it is to work for the community, will require significant staff time for research and community engagement.

And it will likely only get worse.  All projections, even if there is a downturn in the economy, are that South Frontenac will feel increased development pressure for many years. One of the strategic objectives Council adopted four years ago, and reaffirmed last spring, was greater enforcement and control on development so that the needs of the community and new residents are protected.

Staff’s response to this priority for Council and residents was to recommend a new position to work on planning policy development and compliance. Until the January all-day budget meeting it seemed like all of Council supported this proposal and it could be implemented within the 2% budget increase Council supported.

At the last minute, the Mayor and a few Councillor’s, expressed opposition to this position despite the fact that is affordable, addresses residents’ concerns, meets our strategic objectives and will help improve South Frontenac. Let’s see how the final vote goes.

Library and Fire Hall Safe

The Township needs more administrative office space.  The initial proposal was for consultants to look at five different options, three of which involved moving the existing library.

I did not support moving the library as an option, even for study.  It is a well-designed and well used library that is within walking distance for many people. There is no reason to pay money for comment on possibilities that shouldn’t happen.  The community overwhelmingly agreed, thank you to all who spoke up, and Council limited the consultant’s report to two options, expanding the current building or buying/building a smaller space nearby in Sydenham.

The fire halls’ locations were evaluated in a facility location study.  The study’s main finding was that South Frontenac’s fire hall’s locations are as good as they can be, often near perfect (Sydenham’s location).

There is some room for improvement on the exact location of the Latimer and the Hartington stations.  There would be a small improvement of service if the Hartington Hall, when it is redeveloped, is rebuilt closer to Harrowsmith: a fact that will likely become increase in importance as more building takes place closer to Harrowsmith.

No Building Fee Increases

In the annual review of building fees, it was discovered that the building department has built up a large, close to a million dollars, reserve.  This increase is due in large part to the shortage of staff over the past few years: it was money saved by not paying salaries, but also by providing poorer service to the community.

The cost of the building department is mandated to pay for itself through fees: there is no tax revenue supporting building services.

Council has placed a cap on the building department reserve, basically enough money to run its operation for a year.  The result is that there should be no increase in building permit fees for a few years, until the reserve falls below the new cap.

Sub-Division Approval Coming Home

A long-standing goal of Council has been to bring final approval of sub-divisions back into South Frontenac.  It is currently done by the County.

One of the steps needed to make this possible was improving our planning department, which has been very successfully done. During the budget discussion it was confirmed that Township staff have been talking with the County’s planning staff about this goal and that there is general support.  The next necessary step is to finalize our new Official Plan, which should be done this year.

Bringing final approval of sub-divisions into South Frontenac Council will improve community control and accountability on development decisions.

Posted in South Frontenac Township | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

January 2022: Plant Flowers

There is a social media cartoon meme that has two characters talking about 2022.

One with a worried look says, “What do you think is going to happen in 2022?”

The other says, “Flowers”.

“What? Why?” The first responds in startled confusion.

“Because I am planting flowers,” reply’s the one working the ground.

For many reasons, pandemics, climate change, uncontrolled development, invasive species, inequality, intolerance…(the list is long) we are entering a year, and probably a decade, of significant, and not always welcome, change. Nonetheless, we can plant seeds that help others, make our communities inclusive, strengthen our democracies, and create a more peaceful, sustainable and just world.  

Onward into 2022.

Johnson Point Update

A few weeks back I sent around a notice about a possible violation of the environmental protection plans for the Johnson’s Point condominium development.

Dozens of people responded.  Within a couple of days an agreement was reached with the developer to ensure that the septic location conditions were met for all the lots on Johnson’s Point.

Over the holidays I was telling a friend, who is very active in provincial environmental issues, about the protections covering the Johnson’s Point development. He was very pleasantly surprised.  It is worth repeating that even though many in the community were upset that any development is taking place on the Point, me included, gains were made.

Hats off to the many who spent hours and their own money fighting for better environmental protections.  

Councillor and Community Oversight

While the discussion last month was on ensuring that the Johnson’ Point development met its environmental obligations it was also broader.

Most the comments I received were primarily concerned that conditions of approval, bylaws and regulations, especially for larger developments, are followed.  We on Council have known for a long time that non-compliance is an issue and hopefully we will be able to make further headway in solving it.   

Some of the comments suggested that Council should proceed quickly because of agreements made by the developer and hardship to lot owners.

Many councilors and community members may be more familiar with the Committee of Adjustment than site plan approvals. Regularly, someone applying for a variance or a consent will demand quicker action became of their personal circumstances. Staff have made good headway in setting up timelines and streamlining the process for all developments, big and small, which have reduced delays for everyone.

Nonetheless, as much as some applicants, or developers, may have legitimate hardships, this is also, unfortunately, not a good reason to rush a decision. 

The Committee of Adjustment decisions, as the Council decisions on sub-division and condominium site plans, affect these properties, the broader community and the environment for decades.  Township Council, and the Committee of Adjustment, have the final legal say on these kinds of approvals, not because our staff are incompetent, they are not.  South Frontenac has some of the best planning staff. But because these decisions are a mix of technical, legal and political considerations. 

Site plans are, literally, the nuts and bolts of how development happens on the ground.  It is what we see in our communities, and impacts our environment, on a daily basis for years. The more complex the development the longer it is going to take to review the plans, to diligently fulfill our legally independent role, and to not just rubber stamp what staff and developers, big and small, recommend. This is part of our democratic responsibility to represent the broader community interest.

Final say on developments is made in democratic public bodies, like Council, because it is a more accountable forum which gives the community some control over development. To rush these decisions would be to undercut that control.

Township Office Redevelopment

The Township offices are unable to provide a safe and efficient working space for current Township staff let alone the expected expansion to meet population growth and new needs. 

Council has approved 2.5 million dollars to improve our administrative offices over the next two years.  Consultants are being hired to present options which include expanding the current site, repurposing the library and building a new one, and adding a secondary site in Sydenham.  The report can be found in the December 14 Committee of the Whole agenda item 7.c.

 

Posted in South Frontenac Township | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Last Minute Proposals Weaken Johnson Point Development Environmental Protections

Site Plans presented to South Frontenac Council for a 15-lot development on Johnson’ Point will weaken environmental protections ordered by the Ontario Municipal Board (OMB) as a condition of approval for this estate-lot condominium.

The Johnson’s Point proposal on Loughborough Lake has been the focus of many community concerns about its negative effect on the surrounding provincially significant wetland and the already crowded lake.  After years of public debate, in 2016 the OMB approved the development, subject to conditions that offer some protection for the surrounding environment.

One of the conditions, 13(ii), states that as well as a septic system, each lot will have “A location for the alternative septic disposal system…”  identified on a site plan before applying for building permits. In the site plans presented to Council, two of the lots did not have an alternative septic system location.

The rationale for a second location is that if the first fails there is a safe way to treat sewage with minimal environmental damage. This requirement is even more important for a development in an environmentally sensitive area.

Leaving the alternate septic site off the site plans raises two concerns:

  1. The Township and citizens’ groups spent many months and significant resources on lawyers and consultants to negotiate plans at the Ontario Municipal Board that permitted the lots in exchange for specific environmental protections.Site plans that violate one of these conditions may be illegal. Regardless they certainly undercut public trust in the process.Approving the lots without a secondary site will say that even limited protections can be simply overturned in favour of the developer’s profit while the environmental and the community needs are ignored.
  2. This omission increases the risk to the environment.It may be small increase, but wetlands are not only one of the most important of our natural features for preserving water quality and species diversity; they are also one of the fastest disappearing. We need to be increasing protection of wetlands not incrementally increasing the threats.

This chipping away at gains made by the community has contributed to a lack of faith in the Township’s ability both to control development and to make developers live within the rules.

Until site plans meeting the conditions of approval can be developed neither the Master Site Plan nor the site plans for lots 2 and 14 should be approved.

The Ontario Municipal Board Conditions of Approval were clear, and the result of much work by many residents, lawyers, Councilor’s, and professionals. There is a significant obligation to respect this decision and improve our local environment.

Consideration of the site plans will be coming to South Frontenac Council on December 21.  If there are concerns about approving site plans that are at odds with the OMB Conditions of Approval now is the time to raise them with your representatives and your neighbours.

Posted in South Frontenac Township | Tagged , , | Leave a comment